Showing posts with label pseudo Historical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pseudo Historical. Show all posts

Saturday, 17 October 2015

70: The Time Warrior

Before Watching

Since Dennis Spooner’s “The Time Meddler” we’ve had precious few pseudo-historicals like this, that is stories set in the Earth’s past, yet with a definite science fiction element other than the Doctor and companions arriving via time machine. In fact, the only one that comes to mind is “The Evil of the Daleks” and that didn’t do a great deal with Victorian Britain, which was after all only one of the locations of the story.

I’m not entirely sure why. After all, one of the essential problems with the pukka Historicals was that either they became pure adventure stories where the past is merely used as a kind of wallpaper, like the late Historicals, “The Smugglers” and “The Highlanders”, or you had the Doctor and companions being essentially bystanders and observers, the audience to History, but not participants within it. In a pseudo Historical you avoid this problem, since it’s pretty clear that the Doctor must act in order to prevent the course of History being diverted. Classic Who, though, continued to steer clear of this kind of story for a long time after “The Time Meddler”. In that story you may recall the Meddling Monk’s plan was to use 20th century weapons technology to defeat Harald Hardrada before the battle of Stamford Bridge, sparing Harold Godwinsson the effort, and ensuring him victory at Hastings. Well, Hastings was a real, pivotal, Historical event. The next time that the Doctor would actually be trying to prevent a real Historical event from being wiped out of History wouldn’t be until season 20’s final story, “The King’s Demons” where the Master plans to prevent the signing of Magna Carta.

Look, I can’t lie to you. I watched this one again last year on the Horror Channel. I’m sorry, but I can’t be expected to sit there idly twiddling my thumbs while they’re showing a classic, Robert Holmes – Jon Pertwee story. I know what happens, I know what it’s like – I know the goodies that are within – the debut of both the Sontarans and my favourite classic companion, Sarah Jane Smith. Actually, I’ll be interested to see over the next couple of series whether Sarah Jane manages to stay in that enviable position  - Jacqueline Hill’s Barbara is a serious contender for the crown too.

After Watching

The first thing that struck me about the new title sequence was how unhappy and old Jon Pertwee appears on it, compared with the smiley, short haired Pertwee whose ginning phizzog has welcomed us to every episode previously. Maybe it’s a good job that this is a Robert Holmes story, and a four parter to boot, to get him back into the swing of things.

The story opens in the late12th/ early 13th century. The earliest action is centred on the castle of Irongron. Irongron is a bandit, who is a bit like Robin Hood, in as much as he robs the rich, although he hasn’t got around to giving it to the poor yet. Irongron is played by David Daker, a very well known face on TV in the 70s and 80s. He was the baddy in Richard O’Sullivan’s rather lacklustre “Dick Turpin”, and is possibly best remembered as Harry Crawford in “Boon”. With his lived in face David Daker was never going to be cast as shrinking violetty, sensitive types, and I doubt that his Hamlet would ever have been much to write home about. Cast him as a thug like Irongron, though, and he’d always do a throroughly good job for you. And in this Robert Holmes script he has quite a bit of good stuff to work with.

Supplies are running low, when Irongron and his wingman Bloodaxe see what looks like a shooting star. They ride out to where it came to Earth, and find a small space capsule which contains a warrior in a metal helmet. The Time Warrior, after claiming Earth for the Sontaran empire, enlists Irongron’s help, promising to give him new fangled weapons which will help him overcome any of his enemies. And all this in the first 6 minutes or so.

Using this time to set up the situation with Irongron and Linx, the Sontaran, means that when we do cut straight to UNIT we don’t need a long exposition scene telling us about disappearing scientists – we work out what is happening, and put two and two together to link it with Linx. It also gives a little more time to introduce Sarah Jane Smith. Sarah Jane, played by the late beautiful and talented Elisabeth Sladen, is a journalist, who is posing as her Aunt Lavinia, a famous scientist, to investigate exactly what is going on. When another Scientist, one Professor Rubeish, a scientist who is a prime example of the ‘dotty old fool’ variety thereof, disappears, the Doctor uses a doohickey to get a fix on where he has gone. Sarah goes rooting about in the TARDIS, just before the Doctor decides that it’s a case of tally-ho, the game’s afoot, and sets off after him. Amazingly the TARDIS makes a near perfect landing.

At the end of episode 1 Linx raises his helmet and we get our first sight of the head of a Sontaran. The Sontarans, although not always used to the best advantage, would reappear another 3 times in classic Doctor Who, in “The Sontaran Experiment”, “The Invasion of Time” and “The Two Doctors”. One interesting fact is that their appearance changed, slightly but noticeably each time they appeared – which doesn’t really matter than much apart from the fact that they are supposed to be a cloned species that are absolutely identical to each other. The Sontarans, although the last of the great recurring monsters to appear in classic Doctor Who (by which I mean the Daleks, Cybermen, Ice Warriors and Sontarans) they would actually appear in the post 2005 series before the Ice Warriors were exhumed.

The action, then, remains in the medieval milieu. Irongron wants ‘modern’ firearms so that he can attack and defeat his near neighbour Edward of Wessex. Sarah Jane, after escaping from Irongron’s clutches with the help of the Xeron leader from “The Space Museum”, Jeremy Bullock, who plays Hal the Archer. It’s quite forgiving of him since Sarah Jane distracts him when he is about to shoot Irongron, and thus ensures that he is captured and his life is in danger. Thus when they reach the castle of Edward, we find that in fact on the side of the goodies we have Lord Beardy of Weirdy, Lady Dot of Cotton and Sir Boba of Fett. June Brown is a terrific actress who has rightfully received plaudits for her long lasting role in “Eastenders”, and while Lady Eleanor isn’t the meatiest role she’ll ever have played she imbues her with a certain steeliness which mirrors Sarah’s own , for it’s Sarah who persuades Edward to stage an attack on Irongron.

Episode two sees the meeting between Linx and the Doctor which reveals his plan. His capsule has some elementary time technology, which enables him to seize scientists from the 20th century – that-s the furthest range that the power source of his capsule will allow. The scientists are then fitted with mind control devices, and used either to carry out the necessary repairs on Linx’s capsule, or to fashion the firearms that Linx has promised Irongron. The Doctor reveals, for the first time, that he is actually from Gallifrey, prompting Linx’s famous observation that the Time Lords have great power, but lack ‘the morale to withstand a determined assault’. And from that throwaway line will come one of the less successful Tom Baker stories in the shape of “The Invasion of Time”. That’s in all of our futures for now, though. It’s been a while since we’ve come back to the issue of whether you can change history or not. The only previous time in Jon Pertwee’s tenure was in “Day of the Daleks”. The third Doctor’s reaction to Linx is completely consistent with his reaction to the Monk in “The Time Meddler” – his meddling with Earth history would be disastrous, and he will not allow it to happen.

In fact, the more I think about it the more the comparison to “The Time Meddler” seems an apt one. There’s the obvious connection with the setting – alright, there’s more than 100 years between 1066, and the dawn of the 14th century which is when this one is set, but that’s really not a great difference in terms of the culture and society of the times, certainly not as far as Hollywood or TV drama is concerned anyway. Then rather more subtly, there’s the tone. Yes, there are some nasty things that happen in this, or that nearly happen, I should say, but overall the tone of both is of a historically based romp, with a vein of comedy and fun running through it. Not that Linx is a comic character as the Monk is. But in “The Time Warrior” the funny lines are spread out between several of the characters, thus we get Irongron’s memorable description of the Doctor as ‘a long-shanked rascal with a mighty nose’, and then when The Doctor tells professor Rubeish that he is looking for Sarah, ‘I’m looking for a girl’, Rubeish muses ‘I would have thought he was a bit old for all that.’

Now, a short digression, which will, hopefully, make sense in the fullness of time. Superman, the archetypal superhero was created in the early 30s by schoolboys Jerome Seigel and Joe Shuster, and eventually sold to DC comics where he made his first appearance in Action Comics no. 1 in 1938. When he first appeared, Superman didn’t fly, and once of the claims made about him was ‘nothing short of a bursting (artillery) shell could pierce his skin’. Soon his super leaps became flights, and the claim had been changed to ‘not even a bursting shell could pierce his skin’. Superman soon became so super that it was totally unbelievable that anyone could ever so much as inconvenience him, let alone defeat him. Which is why the writers of the time came up with the concept of kryptonite. For those unfamiliar with it, basically Superman was sent to earth from his home planet of Krypton by his parents when he was a tiny baby, because Krypton was about to explode. Kryptonite is pieces of the core of the exploded planet. At first there was just kryptonite – which came to be known as green kryptonite, a short exposure to which robbed Superman of his powers, and a long exposure to which would kill him. In time this would be joined with other colours of kryptonite which would have different effects.

Now, what this has to do with Doctor Who is that the more powerful a monster, the more there needs to be a kryptonite, a weakness which can be exploited to defeat them. With the cybermen, to pick one example, their ‘kryptonite’ has been, at different times, radiation, gravity, acetone, gold and so on. Now, in “The Time Warrior” Sontaran kryptonite comes in the form of the probic vent. Remember, the Sontarans are a genetically engineered species, and instead of the inefficient refuelling means we humans use, that is, eating and drinking, they refuel through an orifice which is called the probic vent. Now, the probic vent is really and truly the only part of a Sontaran that is vulnerable- extremely vulnerable as it happens. So, bearing in mind that they are a genetically engineered species, their designer must have been having a really bad day when he decided to put the probic vent on the back of their necks, where they can neither reach it, nor see any danger approaching it. It’s the only real criticism that I have  of the Sontarans, that their kryptonite is so obvious. Linx isn’t defeated because he is outthought, or out-technologied by the Doctor. He is defeated because Hal the Archer gets one lucky shot at the probic vent. And it’s a shame, since the Sontarans otherwise have a hell of a lot going for them. In most ways they are more interesting and far more adaptable than, by way of comparison, the Cybermen. Could you ever see a cyberman being used in the same way as the revived series has used Dan Starkey’s Strax for comic effect as a member of the Paternoster Gang? I rest my case.

All in all then, if we’re prepared to lavish praise on Robert Homes – and I am – we must also apply criticism where it is due. So this isn’t quite an all-time Holmes classic for me. But it is what it is, a very enjoyable slice of late-Pertweeana, and there’s much to enjoy here.

What have we learned?

Practically everything important we’ll need to know about the Sontarans

Sarah-Jane Smith is as gutsy and brave as Jo Grant, but more feisty too. She’s a keeper. 

Friday, 22 May 2015

38: The Abominable Snowmen

Before Watching

This one has a special place in my heart, and it’s all because of the Target novelisation. Terrance Dicks’ “Doctor Who and the Abominable Snowmen” was the first novelisation based on a Troughton story to be published back in about 1975, and that’s exactly when I read it. Now, you have to remember that I was in the primary school at the time, so not necessarily the most demanding or discerning of readers. Nonetheless, the story struck an instant chord with me, and it’s one that I’ve often wished would be found. I can remember the story in the novelisation very clearly, not least because I found out last year that the book was available for the kindle for a couple of quid, and so I downloaded it more quickly than you can say Padmasambhava.

As for the TV story, well, again, I do have some previous with this story. Many years ago, and we must be talking about the early 1990s here, UK Gold had a Doctor Who weekend, one of the delights on offer being that they were showing episode 2, the only existing episode of “The Abominable Snowmen”. I vaguely remember being slightly disappointed, although not why I felt so.

One more word before we start then. A quick google brings me the joyous piece of information that Henry Lincoln, co-writer of this story, is indeed the same Henry Lincoln who went on to make a decent packet of money with that piece of glorious hokum, “The Holy Blood and The Holy Grail”.

After Watching

Oh, isn’t it nice sometimes when something you enjoyed so much as a kid isn’t revealed to your adult self to be a piece of rubbish. Or put it another way, I thoroughly enjoyed that. I loved the start of the story, where it was obvious that the Doctor had been having adventures which we knew nothing about. When he realizes he has landed near the Detsen monastery in the Himalayas he remembers he has been there before, during a time of strife and troubles, when he took their holy ghanta – a sort of decorated bell – into safe keeping. So his motivation for leaving the TARDIS to visit the monastery is clear, he is fulfilling his promise to return the ghanta. That isn’t the most complicated plot device, but it does, in a very understated way, underline what must be a great source of sadness for the Doctor. Even when he does land in a familiar place, all the people he knew there are likely to be long dead, or not even born yet. Also it underlines how Padmasambhava’s life has been extended by the Great Intelligence, since he was there the last time the Doctor visited, a couple of hundred years earlier.

This story illustrates what Doctor Who – indeed the best family dramas – can do. It is perfectly possible to take the story and enjoy it as just an adventure story, which it is, but there is some more to it than that. If you take Padmasambhava, here we have what was obviously once a good man, who has been taken over by the Great Intelligence, and had his life prolonged several times beyond its natural span. All what is left of his own will wants to do is to accomplish the nefarious purposes of the great Intelligence, so that it will leave him and he can die. Now, this never occurred to me when I read the book, but the Doctor, although he gives conflicting reports of his own age, may well be centuries older than Padmasambhava.

I don’t find the Yeti scary. That’s not surprising. I don’t find the Daleks, Cybermen, Ice Warrirors, Sontarans scary now, although they have each sacred the bejesus out of my in their time when I was a lot younger. I find it really hard to decide whether the Yeti would have scared me that much when I was younger. I suppose that when you cover anything, however big, in that kind of fake fur you are always inviting comparison to a giant teddy bear. Or the honey monster. Or some of the larger muppets. They’re probably much scarier in close up, where you can see what appear to be nasty looking claws. I really like the idea of the control spheres, though. It just adds another layer of sophistication to the threat that the monsters pose, that when you think they’re harmless because they have been deactivated, all it takes is for one of those wee silver balls to roll its way into the chest cavity and whoops apocalypse.

Well, let’s get down to brass tacks. The plot. The TARDIS lands close to the Detsen monastery in Tibet. The Doctor has been here before, and recognizes the chance to return the Holy Ghanta he agreed to look after for them. When they reach the monastery they don’t get anything like the warm welcome they expected. The monastery is having a bit of a problem with them pesky yetis, and the situation isn’t helped by the presence of Professor Travers, a British yeti hunter, played by Victoria’s (Deborah Watling’s) real life dad.

It transpires that the aged master monk, Padmasambhava, who was there when the Doctor previously visited the monastery a couple of centuries earlier, was whizzing along the astral plane one day, minding his own business, when he was met and taken over by the Great Intelligence. Over many years, working under the Great Intelligence’s influence, Padmasambhava has stealthily built the yeti robots, that will carry out what needs to be done to enable the Great Intelligence to take on corporeal form, and then consume the whole world nyaaahh haa haaaahhhhh! After much toing and froing and all kinds of how d’you doings the Doctor helps the monks stand firm against the yeti when they attack the monastery, and together they defeat Padmasambhava, and along with him, the Great Intelligence.

It’s maybe not a great work of science fiction, but there’s the rub. This is an adventure story, and as such it gives director and cast an ample amount to work with to create a very exciting and enjoyable Doctor Who story, all the more praiseworthy considering that this is a 6 part story. I found the whole thing very atmospheric. This is a little surprising since, my overwhelming image of the Himalayas is huge jagged peaks, and snow. Lots of snow. In this story there is not so much as one flake in sight . . . and nobody mentions it! What a stroke of genius! You can’t help noticing the lack of snow at first, especially, I found, in episode 2, which is the one episode currently in the archives, but after a while, because all of the characters seem to think that this is perfectly normal, and because nobody else mentions it, then you really just come to accept it, even though the Himalayas never really stop looking like rolling welsh hillsides – which is exactly what they are, I think.

The cast give it their all though, without necessarily going over the top. I didn’t realise that Wolfe Morris, who played Padmasambhava was the brother of Aubrey Morris. Even if you don’t know the name, you’ll know the face, as Aubrey Morris is an English character actor who has been in tons of stuff over the years. I remember him particularly as the captain of the Golgafrinchan space Ark in the tv version of Douglas Adams’ “Hitchhikers’ Guide to the Galaxy”. That was Aubrey, though, and this is Wolfe. He’s quite different physically from what I expected – some wizened, drained little husk of a man – being a little on the large side – but he makes up for it with the way that he uses his voice. The Padmasambhava voice that he uses most of the time is calm, soothing, almost mellifluous. However the voice he produces for the Great Intelligence is almost the complete opposite – in many ways the pure evocation of motiveless evil. Quite a tour de force when you consider that these voices are being produced by the same person, often within the same sentence.

Thematically, well it’s not the most complex story, and for me basically boils down to the main theme, that of men of peace – Buddhists – being confronted with the need to take action, and stand up and defend against violence, using whatever force they can bring to bear. As much as “The Daleks” is about the Thals shedding their pacifism to take control over their own destinies, so it is here, with the monks in the place of the Thals. As I mentioned earlier, though, the figure of Padmasambhava adds another thematic level to the story.

Sometimes with a partially missing story, you get the idea that it wouldn’t necessarily be enhanced all that much if the episodes were found. I honestly don’t think that this is the case with “The Abominable Snowmen”. This is a story that I thoroughly enjoyed.

What Have We Learned?

The Himalayas can be a snow free zone.
The Great Intelligence is neither great, nor particularly intelligent.


Sunday, 29 March 2015

17: The Time Meddler

Before Watching

I watched this one for the first time a good few years back, when UK Gold were showing a complete series on a Friday night. My memory of it is sketchy – I remember enjoying a lot of the Doctor’s dialogue with the Monk, and the scenes with the Monk’s TARDIS, but that’s about all. The Saxon and Viking stuff is a blur to me – I know that there’s Saxons and Vikings in it, but that’s about as far as it goes. The first on screen meeting with another Time Lord, though – that’s got to be worth watching. It’s scripted by Dennis Spooner, so there are going to be some laughs along the way too, I should imagine.

After Watching

What a smart move it was casting Peter Butterworth as the monk. I can imagine the director saying to him –
“Pete, you know that character you play in the Carry on Films?”
“Which one?”
“All of them. Can you play the Monk like that, only tone down the lasciviousness?”
So what you get is a wonderfully mischievous character, who you find it no trouble to forgive for locking William Hartnell in a cell – let’s be honest, we all wanted to do that at one time or another during the first season. The point of the Monk is that he is not a two dimensionally evil character. In fact, he’s not an evil character at all. What he is, it seems, is a character whose moral compass is skewed differently to the Doctor’s, and to the viewers’ and this often makes for an interesting personality.

Compare the Doctor and The Monk. According to their dialogue, the Monk left – Gallifrey presumably – 50 years after the Doctor did. Yet the Doctor is scrupulous about towing the (Time Lords’) non-intervention party line. Sort of. Whereas the Monk, he does it blatantly. Sometimes for personal gain, but more because he ‘wants to help’ – he envisages jet airliners by the 14th century – and gloriously – because it’s fun! What a wonderful reason for doing anything. What I like about the Monk as well is the contradiction in the fact that although the Monk claims he is only meddling in order to make things better, when Vicky and Steven enter for the first time they find that his TARDIS is full of treasures and works of Art he has purloined from across History. So ‘helping’ obviously means helping himself to a great extent.

At this point shall we remind ourselves about how Steven has come to be in the TARDIS. He turned down the chance to run with the others into the TARDIS when he realised he’d left his little fluffy panda behind him in the Mechanoid City. Having fetched it he just managed to run back into the TARDIS – before the doors closed – without anyone noticing he was there. Really? Well, apparently so. Actually this does allow a lovely scene with the Doctor and Vicki trying to convince Steven that he is actually on a space and time ship. Speaking of which, what is it with Steven and the panda? I mean, am I missing something?

Alright then, to the plot. There are two distinct strands to this story which run together by the end. The most interesting strand is of course, the story of the Doctor’s first meeting with one of his own kind, and his battle of wits with the Monk. The second, less interesting story is the one involving the Vikings and Saxons. The TARDIS has materialised somewhere on the coast of what I presume is North Yorkshire, just prior to the Viking invasion of 1066. The villagers are understandably jittery about strangers, especially when they have to fight off an advance party of Viking invaders. I’ll be honest, I found this part of the story a bit of a bore, and a distraction away from the things I was really interested in which all involved the Monk.

Way back in the mists of time I studied Old Norse Literature and Old English Literature, and some of this involved gaining a pretty useful understanding of English History up to and including the events of 1066. This story does actually raise the interesting question – could Harold Godwinsson have defeated William of Normandy had he not made the lightning march North to defeat the Viking invasion of Haraldr Hardrada in the weeks preceding the Battle of Hastings? Well, since he could have won the Battle of Hastings anyway with just a little change of luck the fairest answer is, yes, maybe he could. The Monk’s plan is to use modern military hardware to defeat the Vikings and save Harold the trouble, and maybe this would have worked. Precisely how this would lead to jet airliners before the end of the 14th century, though, nobody quite explains.

The Saxons and Vikings in this story are, I’m sorry to say, a rather sorry bunch. At least none of the Vikings had horns on their helmets – there isn’t the slightest shred of evidence that real Vikings ever did. Mind you, when the crew leave the TARDIS in episode 1 they immediately find a helmet with horns on it – still, that was a necessity since it enabled the disbelieving Steven to lead the Doctor to make his quip about it possibly being a space helmet for a cow. Steven’s disbelief that the TARDIS can travel through space and time actually leads to some other good lines in the first episode, “Up there is the scanner, those are the doors, that is a chair with a panda on it. Sheer poetry dear boy. Now please stop bothering me.” Going back to the Saxon milieu, though, both Saxons and Vikings are both rather scruffy, and at the same time rather unconvincing. It is rather shocking when the advance party seize Edith, the wife of village headman Wulnoth. When next we see her she is in a hell of a state, and adult viewers can’t help thinking that the Vikings have been practicing one of their favourite occupations on her – by which I don’t mean pillage. Very schocking in what is otherwise quite a light hearted romp for the most part.

Worthy of consideration is the contribution that this story makes about the issue of whether you can change History or not. At no time does the Doctor actually tell the Monk what he told Barbara all those weeks ago. If you really can’t change History, not one line of it, then the Doctor does not need to do a thing, because the Monk will be unsuccessful. The fact that the Doctor does take action to stop the Monk suggests that now he knows full well that you can change History – it is just that you mustn’t. . . Unless it’s absolutely necessary. Now, ok, the series still has several true historicals to go – the Myth Makers – the Massacre of St. Bartholemew’s Eve– the Gunfighters – the Smugglers and The Highlanders – but this story seems to signal a significant sea change in attitude towards Earth History and how it can be used in the series – off the top of my head I can think of The Evil of the Daleks – The Abominable Snowmen – The Time Monster and The Time Warrior which all use Earth’s past as a setting, while essentially being Sci Fi rather than Historical stories.

The ending was a bit rushed, and it’s interesting to see that the Doctor uses the removal of the Monk’s Dimensional Stabiliser to immobilise his TARDIS. In the Pertwee era he immobilises the Master’s TARDIS by removing the dematerialization circuit. This has the effect of shrinking the interior of the Monk’s TARDIS so that the inside actually fits into the stone sarcophagus that it appears to be. Which means that it is too small for the Monk to be able to get inside now. It’s rather cruel too, since the note the Doctor leaves for the Monk does hold out the hope that he may one day return and free him. Yet earlier in the same story, when Vicky and Steven found that the TARDIS had disappeared – actually it had just been covered by the tide – she made a point of saying that the Doctor wouldn’t have moved it, because if he had then he would never have been able to come back, the TARDIS being so erratic.

Overall, this was a new direction for the show, and it was one I rather enjoyed. Which is just as well since, as far as ‘Doctor Who’ was concerned, this was the future, baby.

What have we learned?

The Monk is of the same planet and species as the Doctor
The Monk’s TARDIS is not the same as the Doctor’s. For one thing, his works. For another, it has a drift control which allows it to materialise in space. Hmm – I’ve seen the Doctor’s TARDIS do this later on. Anyway, presuming that the Monk’s TARDIS is later than the Doctor’s (a reasonable assumption since he left Gallifrey 50 years after the Doctor) then on Gallifrey – mark 4 comes later than type 40. Go figure.