Before Watching
I think that there was a feature in this in one of the very first
Doctor Who Weekly Magazines I read in the late 70s, and I remember thinking –
well, this doesn’t seem very good - when I read it. So I’m not expecting
miracles from this one to be perfectly honest. The reviews I’ve read since in
some of the definitive works on the subject really struggle to say much that is
positive about it either. So what have we got to expect from the next four
episodes? Nasty blonde Drahvins, nice ugly Rills, and some rather silly looking
robots called Chumblies. Any more than that, well, we’ll find out over the next
four episodes.
After Watching
Right, well, the version I watched was made of 3 recons and one
surviving episodes. The recons weren’t quite the standard telesnaps versions
I’ve become used to, as wherever possible fragments of live action, and
appropriate bits from other episodes have been stuck in to break up the
monotony. And I’m sorry to say it, but monotony is one commodity of which there
is no shortage in Galaxy Four.
Our heroes arrive on a planet where two alien spaceships have
crashlanded. One contains the Drahvins, and the other the Rills. The Rills
breathe an ammonia based atmosphere, and are therefore unable to leave their
ship – and so they use some rather silly looking round robots. For some
inexplicable reason Vicki decides to christen the robots ‘chumblies’. The
chumblies want to take the travellers to the Rills’ ship, but the Drahvins
intercept them, and take them back to their ship.
Right, the Drahvins. These are warlike humanoid women with identical
uniforms and identical blond syrups. Three of them are soulless, indeed
brainless warrior servants, and the other, Maaga, is the leader, an arrogant
one dimensional piece of work. The Drahvins need to get themselves off the
planet which they believe will blow up in 14 days’ time. Well, they’re right
it’s going to blow up – but in a much shorter timescale. They tell the Doctor
that they were attacked by the Rills, and the crash has rendered their ship
inoperable. The plan is to take over the Rills’ ship, which is supposed to be
operable.
Of course, the ‘pretty’ people are the baddies, while the ugly old
Rills are actually as nice as pie. They never attacked the Drahvins in the
first place, and have already offered to take the Drahvins with them when they
leave the planet. Of course, they need the Doctor’s help to leave – he
recharges their ship from the TARDIS with about 20 minutes to spare.
There really isn’t a lot more to the story than this, and it’s
pretty dire, when all is said and done. In episode 3 Maaga gets what is
probably meant to be a serious monologue about how soul destroying it is to
only have the company of these warrior ‘drones’ who don’t have a though in
their heads, but her own behaviour before and after this means that it is
actually out of place and out of character. Then there is the question about
who you should believe and who you can trust, when Steven is left alone in the
Rills’ ship, and they have to break through his scepticism. But it’s heavy
handed at best. The visuals, while no worse than, say, The Sensorites and The
Keys of Marinus do nothing to detract from the poverty of the script.
I think that this is my least favourite William Hartnell story so
far. It’s just so . . . terminally bland. All of the cast try their best at
different times, but nobody rescues this leaden production. It hasn’t got much
going for it at all – after all what can we say positive : -
-
Its
heart’s in the right place
-
It’s not a
6 parter
-
Umm – that’s
about it really.
What
have we learned?
Including this story and ‘The Daleks’ the score currently stands at Mingers – 1, Pretty People 1.
No comments:
Post a Comment